147

Coda from Panic Software Reviewed

Coda has landed!Nothing brightens up a Saturday morning hangover like toys I’m not supposed to have in my inbox. An anonymous tipster (thanks Mike!) dished me a copy of Panic Software’s new developer workflow application Coda today. If you remember I was just a little bit hot and bothered about this yesterday. The app is supposed to officially debut Monday but I don’t see why I can’t give you guys my own first impressions with a full on exclusive review.

I do web development pretty much every day and have never been a real fan of the all inclusive, live editing types of tools. Honestly tools like Dreamweaver really makes me cringe. So like many others I normally have a separate application for text editing, FTP, shell, and of course a few browsers open. I have to tell you, I’ve taken the red pill now and doing away with all of these separate tools actually seems possible with Coda.

So in case you haven’t already guessed, from within Coda you can use FTP, terminal, preview, a CSS editor, and of course live edit your remote files on the fly. When I first launched Coda it sucked in all of my details from Transmit (another Panic app) with a quick import. From there I was met with a jaw droppingly gorgeous live preview of my website, where I could enter my remote/local, FTP, and shell details.

Enter your details

I guarantee you will be impressed by the user interface in Coda. I never used to be impressed by jazzy special effects, simplicity, and elegance in my applications, but Panic really delivers on this front. If this type of thing gives you wood, prepare to be really dazzled when working with this tool.

But the real bread and butter of an app like this is its live editing feature. Some of the other workflow apps I’ve used really don’t handle the remote editing of files that elegantly. When you live in Bangkok and your working on servers in the US, trust me, you will feel the latency. After working with Coda all day doing just this type of work, I can say I am very satisfied, and even a bit surprised. As with Transmit a connection loss is transparent to the user, meaning you never know you got disconnected.

Which brings me to the built in editor. For me this is really the deal maker. One of the problems I have had switching to a Mac is the editors on OS X. They aren’t bad, but they aren’t great either. Having said that, I think the guys at Panic are off to a really great start with their own editor. All of the usual languages are supported and styled appropriately including: CSS, HTML, Javascript, Java, Perl, PHP, Python, Ruby, SQL, XML, and straight text.

A sporty editor

Okay here is something I really like about the editor. I hit command+f and from the top of the file I’m using shimmies out a find/replace text bar. I really like stuff like that at my fingertips. You really get the impression with Coda that the guys at Panic build apps that they themselves would use. The editor is certainly not as robust as something like BBedit, but I seriously don’t think it has to be.

Coda also comes packed with a CSS editing tool. I’m not a real fan of these but I actually found myself using it quite a bit. One thing I can say is that if you are a newbie with CSS, Coda might just be your best friend. Stashed off in one of the tabs is a books section which was outfitted with the PHP manual and 3 others. I didn’t see an option to add your own books, or how this could even be done, but having all of my dev literature in one place is a pretty remarkable concept.

Coda has Books!

I think the really great thing about Coda is its tabbed layout that allows me to switch from editing a file, to my terminal, to a quick preview of my work. I am a bit of a slob and will often have a dozen files open for editing at once, and Coda handled my bad habits surpisingly well. I can honestly say that from quick edits to even intensive work, Coda adapts and scales like a champ.

FTP functions like it does in Transmit, which is just fine. Coming from *nix the only real gripe I have (and it’s legit damnit!) is the complete lack of a quick path edit line. Without it browsing directories is way more cumbersome than it has to be. But seriously, this my only real complaint, and this is a brand spanking new application.

Salivating yet? If you do any design you should be. Okay, I know what you’re thinking ‘this approach has been made before with dozens of other apps, and it tries to do too much, and it ends up being cumbersome in the end.’ My first impression of Coda is that it is really powerful, yet extremely elegant, and I am being honest when I say I will be using it for my webdev work from now on. It really gels with my worfflow and I would be surprised if I am not more productive using it.

We’ll see how it goes, but after a few hours working with Coda I’m already a big fan. It’s almost guaranteed to be a huge hit with other OS X developers. Be sure to check out Panic’s site on Monday to get your own copy. The copy I have expires in 14 days, and we’ll have to wait until Monday to see what this gem will cost for licensing. In the mean time here are some more screenshots for you to gush over.

UPDATE: Coda has just been officially let loose in the wild. You can grab a 14 day trial here or jump right into a license for $79.00. From the looks of their buy page that price may go up to $99 in the near future. Congratulations to the Panic crew for a timely and slick release. Great work!

I nearly shat when I first saw this.
Ok this impressed me!

Just tell me my motd screen is not r0X0rz.
My MOTD 0wn3z J00!

The CSS editing tool.
The CSS editor

This is the editor’s preference pane.
Editor preferences pane

The terminal preference pane.
Style your terminal

Be sure to subscribe to our full page feeds for more up to the minute Mac app reviews, previews, and giveaways.

114 Comment(s)

Legend: Guest Article Author Contributor
  • 1

    Michael Yurechko said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 7:33 am

    Wow. Nice. I wouldn’t mind getting my hands on that app. I guess I’ll have to wait until monday.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 2

    Freudian said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 7:45 am

    Wow Miles thanks for this, I am indeed drooling.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +2
  • 3

    Donald Perreault said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 8:09 am

    Looks like i’ll be getting out the credit card again ;)

     Add karma Subtract karma  +5
  • 4

    Will said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 9:04 am

    Nice stuff. I really do need to learn web design…

     Add karma Subtract karma  +7
  • 5

    Derek said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 9:39 am

    Amazing looking application. Will this be the single tool able to pull me away from my reliance on TextMate + Transmit + Terminal trio? Easily priced over $30 me thinks.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +6
  • 6

    Daniel said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 9:46 am

    I probably wouldn’t buy it because I already have CSSEdit, TextWrangler, and Transmit, but the amazing graphics and the Books section make it extremely tempting.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 7

    Eric said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 9:47 am

    Dammit.. I have a huge web release coming up. Guess when it goes live? Midnight Sunday.

    Oh, and I bought Transmit LAST NIGHT. I feel… erm.. foolish, to say the least.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 8

    Justin Laramee said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 10:33 am

    Looks really nice. Seems to be the biggest competitor to Flow.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -1
  • 9

    jason said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 10:59 am

    In the article he only seems to mention editing sites on the fly. While this is great for the ’seat-of-your-pants’ programmer in all of us, does it let you edit files on your system and then upload them when ready? This is and always has been the main draw of Dreamweaver for me (I also came from the PC side where DW was the best option anyway). There doesn’t seem to be a program out for the mac that allows easy mirroring of a site locally and then uploading when done. Although it could be done easily with Transmit, Textmate, and CSSEdit. But that’s three programs instead of one.

    @Justin - Sorry to ask a dumb question, but what’s Flow?

     Add karma Subtract karma  +2
  • 10

    Nick said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:01 am

    Sweet. Nice review. Gives a great feel for what is so great about it. One question, tho: what do you mean, “The editor is certainly not as robust as something like BBedit..?”

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 11

    Alec Feld said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:08 am

    Jason,

    http://flowapp.com/

     Add karma Subtract karma  -11
  • 12

    jason said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:19 am

    thanks! there’s also a web-based app coming around sooner or later, i’m in the private beta, but i think you could sign up for it. it’s at http://createworkspace.com

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 13

    Alex Galonsky said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:28 am

    Great review - you should write more!

     Add karma Subtract karma  -6
  • 14

    shadownight said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:34 am

    Did you check with Panic before publishing this review? I’m not sure they’d be too happy about someone completely spilling the beans the day before…

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 15

    Ice Spectre said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:34 am

    Disappointing that you saw fit to ruin Panic’s surprise in the name of an “exclusive” story…

     Add karma Subtract karma  +9
  • 16

    rstevens said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:38 am

    Seriously, did we need to blow the surprise on them for one stupid day of exclusivity?

     Add karma Subtract karma  +7
  • 17

    Jesse Dodds said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:38 am

    Way to go guys… Way to screw Panic! They’ve most likely been holding their cards on this close to their chest for a good reason - The Apple Design Awards. This would’ve been an awesome surprise for everyone. BAH

     Add karma Subtract karma  +4
  • 18

    Jakob Wells said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:41 am

    It’s disgusting that you feel it is important to ruin their surprise so you can catch a few more readers.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 19

    LeberMac said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:43 am

    Panic software has consistently produced EXCELLENT applications for the Mac, I’m sure Coda will be no different. User interfaces are really my thing, and Panic always makes software with excellent ones.

    Unfortunately, I bought a PC yesterday. One of the apps that I will miss most will be Transmit.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 20

    Mike Vitoroulis said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:46 am

    What bad taste. You had to screw Panic over in order to write an “exclusive” post? I guess that’s what happens when you’re desperate for decent content.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +5
  • 21

    Dumb Decision said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 12:03 pm

    Yep, I agree with the others: you’ve shown a complete lack of reespect for the very community your site purports to support and help. If I were Panic, I’d go out of my way to insure that every other developer out there understands what you’ve done.

    It’s wrong, and if you had half a brain, you’d understand why and remove the review immediately.

    Sheez.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +6
  • 22

    Ben said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 12:06 pm

    Honestly, it’s just a day before it’s official release date. I’m glad you posted this. I love Panic and just about everything they do. Their apps are not only incredibly useful and intuitive but their design is gorgeous as well.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 23

    Ryan Humphreys said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 12:06 pm

    You guys seriously are jerks for spilling the beans on this before Panic had the chance to publically announce it. Bad karma MacApper.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +17
  • 24

    Nick said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 12:07 pm

    Wow. Can you feel the love in this room? Crikey. Like this one review will screw Panic over? No way.

    Build it, and they will come!

     Add karma Subtract karma  -5
  • 25

    Nik Coleman said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 12:10 pm

    Fucking hell guys! Its one day. Go fuck yourself. It comes out in like a day!

    Dudes!!!!

    Nik.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -16
  • 26

    Miles Evans said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 12:11 pm

    @Jakob: How did I ruin any surprise? By writing a scathingly glowing review of an app to be released in 24 hours? It arrived anonymously in my inbox and I was never told I shouldn’t or couldn’t write about it. I made the decision knowing the app was to be released in 24 hours.

    @Jesse: I took a look at: http://developer.apple.com/wwdc/ada/. I honestly couldn’t find the part about being nixed from the contest for having your app featured on MacApper.

    @Mike: If our content sucks Mike feel free to vote with your browser. We’ll still be here writing about Mac apps.

    You guys are certainly entitled to your opinon but I think some of you need to seriously lighten up. Go eat some ice cream maybe.

    Also for the record, I emailed one of the guys at Panic yesterday and got no response. If anyone over there asked me to remove this glowing review of their new tool I would remove it. Well, until tomorrow.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -4
  • 27

    Rob said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 12:15 pm

    Looks great, but not sure it will be too pr0 until later in it’s life.

    The terminal thing looks good, but textmate, heddress and transmit are great for simple web work.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 28

    Lime said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 12:25 pm

    “I have had switching to a Mac is the editors on OS X. They aren’t bad, but they aren’t great either.”

    What the hell? I’ve spent hours trying to find an editor on windows that even has half the functionality of BBEdit or Textmate, or even 10% of the elegance of Textmate.

    They’re completely pathetic offerings compared to the Mac world of editors.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 29

    Miles Evans said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 12:33 pm

    @Lime: Who said anything about Windoze dude? I didn’t, you did. I even mention in the article I came from a *nix dev environment. having said that I really do feel homesite4 and ultraedit32 are awesomely robust and mature Windows editors.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 30

    EricaJoy said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 12:34 pm

    This is a nice looking app. I can see I’ll be spending money tomorrow. :)

    (subscribed to comments)  Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 31

    azazel said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 1:10 pm

    I wish I had a Mac.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -5
  • 32

    Juan said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 1:29 pm

    Hmmm… I’m not sure if this review being published a day before Panic’s release is bad…

    I mean, it’s generating publicity for Panic. I mean personally I’m more excited to see it come out tom. The anticipation is a bit higher.

    But all things aside, it was a decent review. Thanks for writing it.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 33

    Jordan Golson said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 1:37 pm

    There is no way in hell that posting this hurts Panic, ruins the surprise or steals their thunder. You have no idea how media works.

    The NYTimes and other papers routinely feed stories to Drudge a day before they go live in order to build MORE buzz about them.

    An exclusive story like this will get more people salivating over what looks to be great software.

    So, quite simply, STFU.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 34

    JoeSmall said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 1:45 pm

    Jason,

    http://forkliftapp.com,
    Forklift Beta 2 released yesterday, now it supports remote editing too.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +13
  • 35

    Brajeshwar said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 1:51 pm

    Thanks for the awesome review. Looks like this will be another must-have app from Panic Software.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 36

    taoski said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 1:52 pm

    Wood?
    Yep… i got it!

    Transmit is a quality client. Can’t wait for this!

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 37

    Timness said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 2:03 pm

    Wow. Coda looks awesome.

    This probably won’t affect the success of the launch, but publishing an “exclusive” review of an unreleased app is sort of a dick move. It’s like finding out that your buddy’s wife is pregnant, and then telling all his friends before he has a chance. It’s still joyous news, you’ve just made an inconsiderate ass of yourself.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +12
  • 38

    Derik DeLong said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 2:13 pm

    This review was not authorized and they requested the screenshots be pulled.

    Not cool guys.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +9
  • 39

    ryan said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 2:19 pm

    You should try TextMate, if you havent already, best editor on any platform (and it solves one issue you mention, quick find, ultra easily and better than Coda seems to (Ctrl-S, ala Emacs, F for find panel and SHIFTF for Find-in-Project)).

    Also, Transmit is not missing a unix path editor field, SHIFTG.

    Lastly, lame that you didn’t get permission to review this before the release date.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +10
  • 40

    xxdesmus said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 2:21 pm

    Great review, but as noted by people above me, it’s a dick thing to do considering 1. the app isn’t public yet, and 2. they didn’t give you permission to do a preview of their app.

    Good idea, horrendous execution. I’d imagine they will be emailing you promptly to have you remove this.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +5
  • 41

    Andre said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 2:39 pm

    Great app, shitty review, shitty site.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +7
  • 42

    Michal said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 2:39 pm

    This sounds really sweet. I’m probably gonna get it.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -3
  • 43

    brent lee said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 2:40 pm

    You rock! Thanks for passing this info on!~!!!

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 44

    droger said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 2:50 pm

    This removal seems a little staged,is it part of the hype?

     Add karma Subtract karma  +6
  • 45

    alej744 said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 2:59 pm

    Wow, f_ck you guys…

     Add karma Subtract karma  -4
  • 46

    salesman said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 3:03 pm

    I have them saved and sell it for cheap

     Add karma Subtract karma  +2
  • 47

    Jordan Golson said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 3:13 pm

    Hahahahah and I am SURE that all of you people bitching about the screenshots NEVER read any rumor sites or look at prerelease screenshots of Leopard or the iPhone right?

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 48

    salesman said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 3:17 pm

    I don’t give a damn about iPhone

     Add karma Subtract karma  -9
  • 49

    Andreas said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 3:37 pm

    Bad form Miles , great way to ruin their surprise party!

     Add karma Subtract karma  +8
  • 50

    clonex said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 3:53 pm

    “scathingly glowing”. Now there’s an oxymoron if I ever heard one.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 51

    Yuzle! said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 4:03 pm

    Dreamweaver’s colour coding is excellent, I agree.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -7
  • 52

    Chris24 said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 4:26 pm

    Looks like a cool app, too bad the images aren’t still available… But It’s a good thing I saved the images onto my computer, so I could take a closer look at them :)

    -Chris

     Add karma Subtract karma  -1
  • 53

    RobH said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 4:52 pm

    It’s about time the Mac had an app like this.

    Textmate and BBEdit are not web IDEs and are too hardcore for my wussy taste. Eclipse is too much of a juggernaut as well. I much prefer the style of some of the Windows apps such as RapidPHP, PHPEdit etc… It seems from this review that Coda is at least somewhat more tilted in that direction than other Mac offerings.

    Not sure about the humongous toolbar though.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 54

    Joe Jacobs said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 5:27 pm

    Wow quality work MacApper…. good job blowing it. No wonder Glenn got out of this site.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 55

    Ted said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 6:15 pm

    As someone who writes several blogs and was a beta tester for Coda, congrats on screwing the pooch. They’ve kept this app under tight wraps and were poised to release it tomorrow with full fanfare, and you guys blew it by trying grab a little thunder from them. Nice.

    No digg for you.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +7
  • 56

    Barry said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 6:30 pm

    Aww I can’t give zero stars? Weak.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 57

    Ari said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 7:21 pm

    Give me a break. Is there is lot of butt kissing going around. If the official release is a day away, I don’t see what the big deal it. A lot of reporters like to get the exclusive on a story. What’s this, bloggers are not “not” journalists. Do we have different rules for different situations?

    Quite frankly, if the official release is a day away, I have to say that I am disappointed in not only the sycophants posting here but in Panic software. Way to live up to your name guys by “Panicking”.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 58

    Miles Evans said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 7:45 pm

    Thanks Ari. Actually I spoke back and forth with Panic a few times today, and they weren’t angry, disappointed, or felt I was a dick at all:

    ‘Hi Miles,

    One of our beta testers absolutely should not have send you the application — we mentioned numerous times that it was covered by non-disclosure, and absolutely not for distribution, and now we’re going to have to spend a bit of time trying to figure out who it was and why they did it. These things happen, but they’re never fun.

    ‘Email removed at the request of Panic.’

    If I myself had signed an NDA agreement not too discuss this application or another, I absolutely would not write about it. Seriously guys. I also had no idea whatsoever about the Coda beta, if participants were required to sign an NDA, or how big the group was.

    Like I said before, it was passed to me anonymously and when I asked my source if I could write about it he said ‘go for it’. Panic knows this and were also clear in their email that they were not upset with MacApper, or me, but the person who leaked the software in the first place as you can see above.

    Maybe some of you folks should familiarize yourself with Fair Usage Guidelines or at least maybe try a post about the subject of the article. A never ending chorus of ‘whaaa you totally ruined the big day’, is just becoming really comical at this point. If the developers aren’t losing any sleep over this, maybe it’s time for you to grab a kleenex and get over it yourself?

    Fo shizzle.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +2
  • 59

    xxdesmus said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 7:45 pm

    It’s pathetic that you tried to grab a few bucks in advertising with your little “exclusive”, and in term screwed over a perfectly great company. Way to go.

    Maybe I’ll get the exclusive story on your wife having herpes, and I’ll just post it on digg a day before I tell you…what a moron.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -19
  • 60

    Miles Evans said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 7:54 pm

    @xxdesmus: If you find her can you let her know that I have indeed discovered that Honey and Dewberry root have indeed kept my ‘condition’ under control? Also tell her sorry from me, and maybe buy her a nice dinner and I can Paypal you the difference. Oh and I just checked my Adsense account for the day and we’re just about to hit $3.50 so ‘nice dinner’ = happy meal is just fine by me.

    *yawn*

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 61

    Alec Feld said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 8:07 pm

    I’ve left out on commenting on this, and now after hearing a bunch of people whining about a birthday surprise, I feel like I have to jump in here somewhere.

    It wasn’t right. Yes, Panic’s app should have been respected and dealt with properly, not being revealed. It could’ve waited a day. Yet, at the same time, I don’t feel as negative about it as everyone else. This stuff happens, stuff leaks, and if I were Miles, I’d be excited to write about it and get the story out there as well. I wouldn’t have known about the NDA or the beta or anything. Are they still gonna sell copies of the app. Yes. Will their overall income or status change over this? Doubt it.

    Again, it wasn’t right. It wasn’t totally wrong either. Miles didn’t know, and thought it was publishable. We learned our lesson.

    This wasn’t for advertising. This was us trying to get our first big scoop. We didn’t screw Panic over, “xxdesmus”. They aren’t losing money or users or status in the Mac community. If anything, more people will have their credit cards out tomorrow to buy this thing.

    At first I wasn’t exactly sure how I should react to the situation, and after a bit it became funny. Really funny. Everyone’s pissed off because a surprise was ruined.

    It was a day early. I back Miles up on speaking with Panic and settling. What’s done is done. We made a mistake, and fixed it. Panic is fine with how things are as of now, so please don’t talk on behalf of them.

    Oh, and “xxdesmus”, maybe I’ll get an exclusive story on how your domain looks like a girl’s MySpace name.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +7
  • 62

    Timness said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 8:08 pm

    Fair use isn’t really relevant here, but no one is saying you’re in any legal trouble for pissing on Panic’s party.

    The only rules you broke were ethical ones — any self-respecting journalist would have at least contacted the company before publishing a review about an unannounced, unreleased bit of software. But you’re not a journalist, you’re a blogger.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -10
  • 63

    xxdesmus-sucks said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 8:15 pm

    You guys are acting like they leaked nuclear launch codes. It’s a mac shareware app, calm the fuck down and get over yourselves.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +9
  • 64

    David Chartier said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 8:30 pm

    I think you should issue an apology to Panic and a brief explanation to new visitors at the *top* of this post to help explain what went wrong. You made a mistake - we’ve all made them. Being completely transparent and honest about this - up front - will speak positive volumes for you.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +5
  • 65

    xxdesmus said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 8:55 pm

    Indeed, I think a lot the reason people are annoyed is that you guys haven’t even acknowledged that you did something wrong here. Yes, leaks happen. As Timness just mentioned above, the responsible thing would have been to email the company AND wait for a reply before you posted this.

    I don’t really care that you think people are over reacting. You’re getting the reaction you’re getting because you’re acting like you’re a perfectly respectable journalist which you’re clearly not.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -7
  • 66

    Mike Cohen said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 9:03 pm

    Editors on OS X aren’t great? There are two awesome editors that I like: BBEdit & TextMate. Each one does some things the other doesn’t so it’s hard to choose one. Maybe Coda will be the perfect editor that can replace both of them.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +5
  • 67

    Patrick said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 9:04 pm

    Wow, this website sucks.

    Not only do you shit on one of the best indie mac developers by spoiling Panic’s surprise announcement, but you then insult those who comment *based on their user names*?

    You guys are a fucking joke.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -8
  • 68

    xxdesmus said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 9:10 pm

    @Patrick

    While I appreciate your defense, don’t even waste your time with these guys. As you said they are a joke, and as such they aren’t even worth arguing with.

    I am really surprised they haven’t started deleting comments that don’t praise them. This is the first time I’ve ever visited Mac Apper, and it definitely will be the last.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -12
  • 69

    Miles Evans said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 9:56 pm

    @David: I have issued endless apologies to Panic via email. I cannot post them here as they have asked me not to (see above where I removed them). In fact, I was told I am not allowed to post anything more than ‘Panic requested us to remove the images’, and nothing else, so I think I will stick to that now and keep quiet.

    In closing I will say that I wish I had never been passed this software, or written the review. I will also say that I was intentionally noncritical in my review of Coda to not ruffle any feathers. I am now realizing how much worse this could have been if I had gripes with the app. Anyways I’ll leave that up to other writers as I’ve had enough heat for today.

    So the last word from me will be: Sorry to Panic and the Mac community. My intentions were good but my execution was lacking. Feel free to continue to vent at me in this thread if it makes you feel better, but I’m gonna move on to something else now. We have some cool stuff in the pipe this week and I don’t think it should take a back seat to this any longer.

    @xxdesmus: Sorry dude you lost me at my wife has herpes? Seriosuly man, If you don’t like the website, and feel we are a joke, I certainly don’t want to waste any more of your time. Feel free to surf off anytime now. And for the record you’re right, I don’t delete comments, as I really loathe censorship - in all its ugly forms.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +17
  • 70

    Freudian said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 10:19 pm

    Apology accepted…You haters reeeaaally need to get over yourselves. Panic too from the sounds of it.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 71

    Michael Yurechko said on

    April 22nd, 2007 at 11:35 pm

    @ xxdesmus

    Honestly, why are you sticking around replying to comments if you don’t like the site. Honestly, just leave, we don’t need your traffic.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +2
  • 72

    David Chartier said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 12:00 am

    Good show Miles. From what Panic told you, it looks like you’re handling this about as well as you can. And you’re right, don’t let the incident keep you down. Just learn the lesson and keep on truckin’.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +9
  • 73

    Jordan Golson said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 12:03 am

    Waaaaaaaaaaah you violated… something… ethics or something….

    Next I’m going to write an email to the NYTimes complaining about how they wrote about Abu Ghraib and Gitmo and warrantless wiretaps when they were violating national security requests from the pentagon waaaaaaaah

     Add karma Subtract karma  +5
  • 74

    Derek said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 12:13 am

    The comments seem a bit heated. In all honesty, these types of leaks happen. However, it is worth noting that waiting until the application launched and then posting this sneak moments afterwards would have still given MacApper the exclusive because no one else would have had time to compose a similar review.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +12
  • 75

    David Chartier said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 12:19 am

    Also, re: the issue with ‘xxdesmus’… If there’s one good idea O’Reilly actually introduced with that silly ‘blogger code of ethics’ bit, it’s this: don’t feed the trolls. Censorship is of course up for debate, but trolls are just like ducks: you keep feeding them, and they’ll keep coming around for more.

    My advise: don’t waste your time with them. Don’t confront them and don’t try to combat their flame bait; basically, don’t acknowledge them because they aren’t contributing to the discussion. If someone is critical that’s one thing; they might very well have something valid to say. But if someone attacks you personally or purports to be the Ruler of All Things (Supposedly) Right and Just™, they probably aren’t here for the party. You dig?

     Add karma Subtract karma  +4
  • 76

    Jeff said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 1:30 am

    Well I am surprised at the foolishness of some of the users on the ineterweb. if you didn’t want to know what it was?

    Easy. you see “Exclusive: Coda from Panic Software Reviewed” in the title. hit the power button on you’re computer. problem solved. and maybe if you really didn’t want to know what it was until Monday. Unplug your internet, get some fresh air. Maybe eat some icecream ;p

    I really like the articles here. keep up the good work Miles.

    On a side note. if you dont like the site. GTFO

     Add karma Subtract karma  +7
  • 77

    Jeff said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 1:38 am

    Eh. typo’s. its 1:30 in the morning. could care less

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 78

    Allan said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 3:05 am

    Two indisputable facts in this discussion:

    1) Miles got a review of an unreleased Mac app
    2) He knew the app was from Panic

    Why wasn’t Panic contacted before publication?

    The fact that Panic has asked for an embargo means
    Miles was wrong. He’s admitted as much, but tells
    the rest of us to move on. A better man would have
    just admitted the mistake, try to do better next
    time, and ignored the peanut gallery.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -6
  • 79

    Thomas said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 3:31 am

    Oh, my g*d, it’s the Muhammad-drawings incident all over again.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +2
  • 80

    Jonathan said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 3:52 am

    It just boils down to courtesy and common sense, neither of which you had.

    A venerated independent software developer announces its “biggest, most ambitious new software launch of all time” (stevenf.com) and you unveil it one day before launch?

    A few dozen people were already testing this application yet strangely enough, no one felt compelled to write about it. Why? Not because they signed an NDA but because they respected Panic.

    You just wanted your fifteen minutes of fame, (ab)using Panic for your moment in the spotlights.

     Add karma Subtract karma  -6
  • 81

    Mary-Ann said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 6:48 am

    Some pretty poor reading comprehension from some of the haters here. Sounds like Panic were contacted, and Panic are pissed off at the leaking beta tester not MacApper.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +9
  • 82

    Dave said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 7:02 am

    Come on guys. The same people complaining here are the ones who cry delighted when new facts about Leopard leak.

    Panic benefits from this posting. A dozen people read the review and can’t wait to see the screenshots when it’s officially released. If i’d be one of Panics marketing people i’d pat on my back, take the marketing budget (which is no longer needed, because this excellent gurillia marketing campaign worked way better, than every payed promotion could have done) and invite the whole panic + macapper team for a nice dinner.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +3
  • 83

    Rant said on

    April 23rd, 2007 at 8:30 am

    Thank you ass…. Now Panic has canceled the announcement and release is pushed back to a unknown time.

    macapper.com sucks BIG TIME!!!