18

Cyndicate: New Kid on the Block

Cyndicate IconThe world of Mac RSS readers is a crowded one. With paid solutions like NewsFire and NetNewsWire, and free ones like Vienna and Google Reader, there are plenty to choose from. Of course, with any RSS reader, there is room to improve. If you have found no other RSS readers on the market that have been able to find the balance between ease of use and power, there is now another alternative, Cyndicate.

Cyndicate v1.0 from Cynical Peak Software was released at the first of August. Being a new player to the RSS game, Cyndicate has some pretty big shoes to fill, but in the end, I felt that Cyndicate did a pretty good job.

Cyndicate

Folder ViewFor almost 6 months, I had been using NewsFire as my default news aggregator. Upon opening Cyndicate for the first time, I was greeted with a view that I was very unfamiliar with. Cyndicate has two main sidebar views, a feed view and a folder view. The feed view gives you a list of all your subscriptions and how many unread are in each. The folder view lets you create folders and assign attributes to each. For example, you can have all of your Mac related feeds dumped into one folder, while your hockey related feeds sort into another.

Cyndicate lets you set up two different folders. The first is just a normal folder, and the second is Smart Folders. You can set up filters in the preferences to filter articles and feeds into normal folders, or just drag and drop articles. Smart Folders work very similar to Smart Playlists in iTunes. You set up criteria, and all articles that fit that criteria are added to that folder.

At first, I wasn’t a big fan of having 2 separate views. Particularly, I didn’t really like the folder view. As I had been using NewsFire for the longest time, I was used to the way that it handled feed reading. In Cyndicate, it’s different. The article is king. Let me just set up a hypothetical situation here. Lets say I am subscribed to 3 different sports sites. I can set up a folder that will have any “hockey” related articles from those feeds filtered into it, while any “football” related articles will be filtered into another folder. In this way you can quickly see all of your hockey related articles without having to dig through multiple subscriptions. It took a bit of setting up to get this system to work for me, but after I was finished, feed reading became much quicker.

This methodology took me a little time to get used to, and it probably will for you as well. If you have primarily used NetNewsWire or another reader for all your RSS reading needs, Cyndicate could be a big change, but can pay off in the end. With that said, there will be those who dislike the way Cyndicate handles feeds and articles. Everyone likes their information presented differently.

Now onto another part of Cyndicate’s interface, the feed item pane. The feed item pane (pictured below) is pretty much your standard view. A blue dot indicates an unread article, and a yellow dot indicates the article has been updated. There are columns that display the subscription, title, author, date posted, rating and size. You can customize the columns to your liking while also adding 2 additional columns (date received and label) which are not turned on by default.

Feed Item View

Clicking an article will display it in the article pane, while also giving you the option of deleting that article. To delete all articles in a subscription, or mark all articles as read, hold down the “option” key to change “Delete” to “Delete All” and “Mark Unread” to “Mark All Read.”

Feed Content

The last part of Cyndicate’s 3-pane view is the article pane. This is were you actually read the article (which I hear is kind of important for an RSS reader). There are 30+ different skins for this pane (I settled on “Daring Blue Bar”) so hopefully you can find one that works for you. You can also change the font and font size.

Permalink

Right-clicking on a subscription in the sidebar will give you a few different options for that subscription. Clicking “Edit Subscription” will bring up a window with information about that subscription, and a few options. the option that I was most interested in is “Display.” You can set Cyndicate to either display the Feed Content or the Permalink Content. Feed Content is just your normal view, while Permalink Content uses webkit to display the webpage where the article is stored. This is useful for feeds that require you to click through to see the entire article.

Edit Subscription

Cyndicate can be customized any number of ways, it’s all about getting it customized to fit your needs. This review—though it may seem long—still doesn’t cover all of Cyndicate’s functionality, so I suggest you give it a try. I know that many of you have found an RSS reader that perfectly suits you, so Cyndicate may not be for you. Though if reading RSS feeds has become a chore for you with your current RSS reader, it may be time for a change. You can grab Cyndicate for $29.95 USD from Cynical Peak Software.

What RSS reader do you currently use? Does Cyndicate sound like an RSS reader that you could see yourself using? If not, why is your current reader better? I have also been working on a review of NetNewsWire 3, so keep an eye out for that in the near future.

17 Comment(s)

Legend: Guest Article Author Contributor
  • 1

    MB-switcher said on

    October 9th, 2007 at 9:56 am

    I personally use vienna…it suits my needs the best (which is having all the news in one place and reading them). I do not need advanced features like “blog this article” etc. so I am sticking with vienna I guess…and the killer argument it’s open source and support is excellent.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 2

    Pete said on

    October 9th, 2007 at 10:42 am

    NetNewsWire Lite is still (as far as I know) free. Also, would you mind using at least a currency symbol when listing prices?

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 3

    mdmunoz said on

    October 9th, 2007 at 10:54 am

    “Lets say I am subscribed to 3 different sports sites. I can set up a folder that will have any “hockey” related articles from those feeds filtered into it, while any “football” related articles will be filtered into another folder.”

    “This methodology took me a little time to get used to, and it probably will for you as well. If you have primarily used NetNewsWire or another reader for all your RSS reading needs, Cyndicate could be a big change, but can pay off in the end.”

    Pretty sure NewsFire, NetNewsWire, and Vienna all do this.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 4

    Daniel said on

    October 9th, 2007 at 4:27 pm

    NewsFire has folders and smart folders. I use them all the time. “+” button > “Smart Feed” or “Group”. It’s one of the coolest features, although I’m sure other RSS readers have them too. Cyndicate is not unique at all in that respect.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 5

    Brad said on

    October 9th, 2007 at 5:04 pm

    Daniel, Cyndicate’s folders differ from NewsFire’s “Group” which are mainly to group together feeds. Cyndicate’s folders are like folders in Mail. You can drag or filter individual articles to them, not just feeds. So you can set up folders like “save” or “read later” and then drop just the articles that meet your criteria for the folder into it.

    mdmunoz, the readers you mentioned don’t do what Greg was talking about. He might not have been completely clear in his description though. What he is talking about is that with Cyndicate’s filtering system you can subscribe to say espn and SI’s feeds. Then create a filter that will only move articles that contain “football” or “hockey” in either their title or the article’s body to the football and hockey folders. You’re not moving the entire feed, just individual articles. This allows you to automatically separate the types of news items that you’re most interested in. It really helps on feeds that have a high noise ratio.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +1
  • 6

    Greg H said on

    October 9th, 2007 at 5:50 pm

    Thank you for clarifying, Brad. And sorry about that Pete, I have added the currency symbol. Not sure how that slipped by me :)

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 7

    mdmunoz said on

    October 9th, 2007 at 7:53 pm

    “What he is talking about is that with Cyndicate’s filtering system you can subscribe to say espn and SI’s feeds. Then create a filter that will only move articles that contain ‘football’ or ‘hockey’ in either their title or the article’s body to the football and hockey folders. You’re not moving the entire feed, just individual articles. This allows you to automatically separate the types of news items that you’re most interested in. It really helps on feeds that have a high noise ratio.”

    You are describing exactly how smart feeds work in every other RSS app. I can make a Hockey smart feed that collects all articles with “hockey” in the title or content. I can do the same for football.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 8

    flec65 said on

    October 9th, 2007 at 8:13 pm

    “You are describing exactly how smart feeds work in every other RSS app. I can make a Hockey smart feed that collects all articles with “hockey” in the title or content. I can do the same for football.”

    Indeed. I can confirm Newsfire can do this with smart feeds.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 9

    Superdotman said on

    October 10th, 2007 at 1:55 am

    Vienna is practically identical, but with an inbuilt tabbed browser and a simpler interface. And it’s free.

    And then there’s the issue of http://www.artofadambetts.com/weblog/?p=203

     Add karma Subtract karma  -1
  • 10

    Jasper said on

    October 10th, 2007 at 3:55 am

    I use Google Reader - I read my feeds on my work machine and my home machine, so it just makes sense to do it that way. If there were a client that sync’d with GR that I could use at home, I would do that - but until that happens, I don’t see myself changing. I do read these RSS reader reviews intently waiting for that feature, though

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 11

    Greg H said on

    October 10th, 2007 at 5:56 am

    @mdmunoz In a way they are sort of like Smart Feeds, but I still think you are thinking about Cyndicate’s methodology a little wrong. The folders act like Smart Feeds, but without the limitations. You can still delete articles from folders, or drag and drop more into a folder. You can’t do this with a Smart Feed. In Smart Feeds, if you want to delete an article, you have to go into the actual subscription and find it.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 12

    Brett said on

    October 10th, 2007 at 7:56 am

    Hey, really great review! Cyndicate’s methodology all sounds just a little too foreign. I use (and love) NetNewsWire 3. Looks great, works great - though some flash integration would be nice… And best of all, it syncs with Newsgator, so I can work cross platforms (Mac at home and Windows at work). I would really love to see your review for NNW3

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 13

    Erik J. Barzeski said on

    October 10th, 2007 at 8:08 am

    @Brett: the methodology is really not all that different. The article is king, not the feed, and I think that’s a far more logical way to work with things. As Greg says himself, “it can pay off in the end.”

    Though Cyndicate uses none of the same code as PulpFiction, the general concept as well as its authors are the same. Some have said of both Cyndicate and PulpFiction that they treat your feeds like email, and that’s true to some extent. But it’s not quite the full story. A blog entry I wrote three years ago still applies.

    I also feel obligated to point out that Cyndicate uses a Bayesian filter to automatically rate individual articles as well. In my own tests as well as those of our beta testers and early users, the rating system is incredibly accurate and can be incredibly useful. Since you can filter or use smart folders based on ratings, you can set up a folder of 4- and 5-star articles, your “must-reads” so to speak. Nobody else does ratings.

    (subscribed to comments)  Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 14

    Nathaniel said on

    October 10th, 2007 at 11:50 am

    I use Vienna, it does everything I need it to do and it’s free.

    Cyndicate does sound interesting, and I’m considering trying it out for a bit. We will see.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 15

    Jack said on

    October 15th, 2007 at 10:02 pm

    It looks pretty nice, I’m going to wait to see Headline for now.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 16

    Greg H said on

    October 15th, 2007 at 10:39 pm

    @Jack: Headline does look like it will be an interesting application. Unfortunately, I think I read somewhere that it will be Leopard-only, so it looks like those planning not to upgrade to Leopard will have to stick with some of the current readers.

     Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 17

    John said on

    November 8th, 2007 at 5:50 pm

    Attensa just released the Attensa for Mac, a free RSS reader which has all the great features mentioned above but goes one step beyond smart feeds with the “River of News” view.

    The “River of News” view simulates a single news feed, regardless of how many feeds you subscribe to.

    With this view we use Predictive Ranking to intelligently predict which subscriptions and articles will be most important. We also allow users to manually rank feeds by simply dragging and dropping the subscription.

    Other RSS readers are just starting to integrate user attention into their RSS readers - something Attensa incorporates into all of it’s RSS readers.

    The Attensa Team

    (subscribed to comments)  Add karma Subtract karma  +0
  • 1 Link(s) Referencing this Post

    More at MacApper

    • Discuss 'Cyndicate: New Kid on the Block' in our new Mac Forums

    Post a Comment


    Post your comment below (spam filtered)