Opinion: Apple, Shape Up Your Changelogs
I recently updated to the most recent release of iTunes. I did this as soon as it came up in my Software Update, as I always try to have the most up-to-date versions of the software on my computer. Newer is better, right? Well, that’s usually been my view, but in addition to some cool new and improved features, there were some things that I was very used to that I now had to learn entirely new ways of doing. This led me to hate the new iTunes, and only after finding ways to recreate old features, which took me some time, could I really accept it as an improvement.
After looking at the changelogs—both the shiny publicized one as well as the more technical support one—I realized that the primary changes that I had issue with were all covered under the phrase “an improved look and feel.” With respect to the geniuses at Apple, this is a terrible way of doing things. The largest way a typical user interacts with a program like iTunes, whether or not it has Home Sharing, Genius Mixes, and the like, is through its UI. We get very used to these interfaces. And yet, there are never any specifics given as to what the changes to the UI actually are. This itself must change.
I’m not saying that the old iTunes interface was perfect, but it was something we were all used to. To suddenly change things around in an interface that makes sense just confuses everyone. Take the new column view, for instance. It is useless to me to have a list of all my artists, and then a small window for the songs. I preferred the old way, when I could have albums, artists, and genres all along the top, while still being able to see the song list below. This doesn’t necessarily mean it shouldn’t have to be changed, but Apple should at least tell us how to make it look the old way. I only found the options for reverting the view by wandering around in the menus for some time.
The playlist and other icons were changed in the sidebar as well. I, personally, don’t really care about this one way or another, but again it brings up the question of why Apple would do this when the old ones worked perfectly well. Is an off-center note more trendy than one in the middle? Is a cut-off gear nicer than a complete one?
About fifteen minutes after upgrading, I had reverted most changes, and made my peace with the new changes that I couldn’t fix. Satisfied with my life, I clicked the green button to minimize the window into the Mini Player I always keep in the corner of my screen. The window simply jumped slightly. Huh. I must have pressed the wrong thing. I clicked again. And again. And again. My world exploded once again. That was the most useful feature of iTunes—to have the display become small and unobtrusive. Had Apple actually gotten rid of this? Luckily, this was not the case; I eventually discovered that you could bring up the Mini Player by pressing Shift+Apple+M. Although this made it possible, it still seems like a stupid idea on Apple’s part. Why make this so much more difficult to do? I’m all for keyboard shortcuts, but if my hand is on the mouse, it would be nice to click. At least, tell me how to make it appear, rather than, once again, making me hunt through menus.
So, I’m not against change. Many of the new features of iTunes are great (I love the new Genius Mixes, among other aspects), but just, tell us about them, okay? An “improved look” is not nearly descriptive enough for me. Make sure that I—and people with less patience for scanning menus—know how to make a program do what it had always done in the past. Progress should not come at the cost of information. We’ll like the updates more if you tell us what’s in them, I swear.
Maybe Apple should concentrate a little more on the, I dunno, music playing? It sounds like an important feature.
Really, if I need to move my lazy hand to the keyboard every time I want the miniplayer, I’m not going to update. A play/pause button on the corner of my screen is kind of one of the most basic things about music playing.
Dude…too many opinions from you man. Do something else like a review or some actual reporting or start your own blog. It’s kinda getting tiring.
Better changelogs would be great.
Just a note, you can Option click the green button as well as Shift-Option-M. I personally like the new behavior better as it is concsistent with every other Mac OS application.
I never liked the inconstancy of green button triggering the mini player in iTunes. But now it doesn’t do anything, as you say it jumps and that’s it. Pointless. What it should actually do is maximise the window.
You can still have Genre/Artist/Album just like before. Just go into the menus and change it from only showing Artists. At the same menu, you can also put it back on top where it used to be before the upgrade.
I agree with your sentiments, though. Sure, change the look of the UI, but don’t change the mechanics of it without clearly alerting users to the changes.
Wonderful post! I really enjoyed it dude
I totally agree. But one feature iTunes really miss is FASTER library managemente with big libraries. With 1Tb collections iTunes is painfully unusable, slow ad f*ck… they have to increase speed, lot of people has got big libraries nowadays.
I understand and even agree with your gripes, but how about sharing your solutions to too?
“About fifteen minutes after upgrading, I had reverted most changes, and made my peace with the new changes that I couldn’t fix.”
Well how did you do that? Thanks none the less.
@scott The main that I had to fix was the columns; if you go to View>Column Browser>On Top, then you’re all set. That, and finding the keyboard shortcut for the miniplayer were the main things. Unfortunately, there was a lot I had to make peace with, haha.
FYI The mini player can also be accessed by clicking on the green plus button as before, only hold down the Option/Alt key while doing so.
The green button is now closer to “maximize”, though it leaves a bit of padding around the window than filling the screen. It was a little surprising when I first tried it, but I find this more useful than the mini player since I use Spaces to keep iTunes out of the way.
I also wish iTunes would stop fiddling with pointless things like just tweaking the icons, making the header shiny, etc. I’d love to see them do a complete overhaul and try to address some of the more major usability issues. The new Genius Mixes feature is interesting, though I couldn’t find a way to drag the playing song into a playlist for future access. It would be much more useful to me if I could play these smart mixes from “iTunes DJ” instead.
Zvuk je z?ejm? z kina, perfekt (viz screen). Vyšlo toho více, tak možná o?ekávejte upgrade fiberglass mesh Vyšlo toho více kt (viz screen). tak možná o?ekávejte upgrade
Zvuk je z?ejm? z kina, perfekt (viz screen). Vyšlo toho více, tak možná o?ekávejte upgrade fiberglass mesh Vyšlo toho více kt (viz screen). tak možná o?ekávejassd
I agree with Jim – review some software and don’t give us just opinions! The only reason I started following this site was for the software reviews to uncover neat little apps.
Sounds like Scott hit it right on. This guy complains that Apple does not provide enough documentation on the changes. Than he says he spent 15 minutes changing things, but, just like Apple, does not tell us how to fix it. Take your own advice!
I have up instructions of modifying iTunes 9 to look more like iTunes 8.
http://www.libertypages.com/clarktech/?p=813
I think your blog is so nice.So I impressed your beautiful expression.I just bookmarked you…keep up the good work!!!!
laptop keyboard
computer keyboard
Computer Accessories